๐ฏ Why this list exists
From the PI Scorecard: of 32 PIs, 5 are graded D (< 30 points), meaning current evidence is too thin for direct media work, public hearings, or parliamentary questioning.
But these issues should not be abandoned โ they are issues government and society "fail to see," and that is precisely why NGO research is needed. This page provides each D-grade PI with a 4-dimensional action plan:
- ๐ Data sources to collect โ specific government websites / statistical yearbooks
- ๐ฅ Interviews to conduct โ which lived-experience subjects / experts
- ๐จ Freedom-of-information requests โ which agency, what specific request
- ๐ Relevant international CO / GR โ which UN General Recommendation applies
CRPD PI-03 ็ฌฌไธๆฌกๅฏฉๆฅ๏ผ2027 ้ ๅฎ๏ผ็ฑๅ่ๆฐ้ๅฝฑๅญๅ ฑๅๅๅก
Score 0 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
- TWSE listed-company annual reports โ women director ratios
- Ministry of Labor (ๅๅ้จ) Form 117 โ average wages by sex
- DGBAS (ไธป่จ็ธฝ่) โ senior management gender statistics
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
- Female CEOs / women directors of listed companies (5โ10 subjects)
- Heads of HR on the promotion ceiling
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
- DGBAS โ labor statistics broken down by job grade ร sex
- Ministry of Economic Affairs โ listed-company ESG gender-governance disclosure
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
- CEDAW GR-25 (Temporary Special Measures)
- CEDAW Article 11 (Employment)
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-06 NHRC ๅฐ CRPD ไน็ฃ็ฃๅ ฑๅ
Score 0 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
- NCC (้ๅณๆ) emerging-media statistics
- MOHW digital sexual-violence reporting
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
- Adolescent victims (with parental consent)
- School counselors
- Social workers
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
- NCC โ platform takedown enforcement
- NPA (่ญฆๆฟ็ฝฒ) โ child online-grooming investigations
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
- CRC GR-25 (Digital environment)
- CRC Articles 17, 34, 37
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-07 ่บซ้้ ็ฎ้ ็ฝฎ๏ผ4 ้จๆ๏ผ
Score 0 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
TBD
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
TBD
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
TBD
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
TBD
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-08 ่บซ้ไบบๅฃ็ตๆง๏ผ็ธฝไบบๆธใ้ๅฅใๅนด้ฝก๏ผ
Score 0 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
TBD
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
TBD
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
TBD
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
TBD
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-12 CRPD ยง24 ๆ่ฒๆฌๅฎๅ่งฃ่ฎ็ญ่ญฐ
Score 0 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
TBD
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
TBD
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
TBD
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
TBD
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-13 ็นๆๅญธๆ กๅญ็บ่ๅฎถ้ท้ธๆๆฌๅ้ๆฏ่ผ
Score 0 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
TBD
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
TBD
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
TBD
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
TBD
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-14 ่บซ้ๅ ๅฐๆ กๅ้ธๅ่่ๅไธๆฏๆไธ่ถณ
Score 0 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
TBD
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
TBD
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
TBD
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
TBD
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-16 ่บซ้่จบๆทๅทฅๅ ทๅ่ๅ ๅฐ้ซ็ๅ็ญ่ญฐ
Score 0 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
TBD
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
TBD
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
TBD
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
TBD
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-17 Disabled Women DV โ Gender ร Disability Intersection (cross-covenant blind spot)
Score 0 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
- MOHW 113 hotline reports โ add disability flag to existing schema
- MOJ Agency of Corrections sexual-violence statistics โ victim disability disaggregation
- NIA marriage-migrant DV โ disability sub-population
- Per-county shelter capacity โ disability accessibility audit
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
- Disabled women survivors (5โ10 subjects, gender-sensitive interviewers)
- Shelter social workers (disability accessibility)
- DV prevention center supervisors (disability-status assessment flow)
- League of Welfare for People with Disabilities โ gender working group
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
- MOHW โ 113 case statistics by disability status (2017-2024)
- Judicial Yuan โ DV protection order applicants by disability status
- County social affairs offices โ shelter accessibility evaluation
- NPA โ 110 emergency-call disability disaggregation
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
- CEDAW GR-19 (1992)
- CEDAW GR-35 ยง28 (2017)
- CRPD Article 6
- CRPD Article 16
- CRPD GC-3 ยง32-37 (2016)
- CEDAW GR-39 (2022)
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-18 Disabled LGBTQI+ โ SOGIESC Intersection (cross-covenant blind spot)
Score 0 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
- MOHW transgender medical advisory committee minutes โ disabled representation
- Tongzhi Hotline service users โ disability disaggregation
- MOE special-education-school gender-equity-curriculum implementation
- NHRC SOGIESC ร disability report (if available)
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
- Disabled LGBTQI+ persons (5โ10 subjects via Rainbow Equality / Tongzhi Hotline)
- Special education school counselors (disabled adolescent SOGIESC)
- Psychiatric Association gender working group (intellectual disability gender identity)
- Transgender legal aid (impact of disability status on gender change)
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
- MOHW โ disability % among gender-change applicants (2017-2024)
- MOE โ disability % in gender-equity-related school disputes
- Judicial Yuan โ disabled LGBTQI+ legal cases
- Household Registration โ disability + gender-change records
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
- CRPD Article 5 (multiple discrimination)
- CRPD Article 6
- CRPD Article 17 (bodily integrity)
- CRPD Article 25
- Yogyakarta Principles plus 10 (2017)
- CEDAW GR-28 / GR-39
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-19 Disabled Indigenous โ Ethnicity ร Disability ร Remote Triple Intersection
Score 0 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
- CIP + MOHW cross-tabulation: indigenous status ร disability certification
- 32 indigenous township healthcare resource table โ disability rehabilitation accessibility
- MOE indigenous students ร special-ed students cross-tabulation
- NHRC indigenous-disability investigation report
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
- Indigenous disabled persons / families (5โ10 across tribes, in-language interviewers)
- Tribal nannies / cultural-health-station supervisors (disability service delivery)
- CIP Department of Social Development (tribal disability service policy)
- Disabled indigenous councilors / tribal assemblies
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
- CIP + MOHW โ indigenous disabled population (status ร type ร tribe ร sex)
- NHIA โ disability healthcare utilization in 32 indigenous townships
- MOE โ indigenous disabled students IEP cultural-sensitivity assessment
- COA / Forestry Bureau โ traditional-territory labor disability accessibility
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
- CRPD Article 4.3 (DPO consultation incl. indigenous)
- CRPD Article 11
- CRPD Articles 25 / 26 (culturally appropriate)
- CEDAW GR-39 ยง54-58 (2022)
- UNDRIP Articles 21-23
- ILO Convention 169
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-15 CRPD ยง12 ๆณๅพ่ฝๅ่ๅฎถ้ท็ฃ่ญทๆฌๅนณ่กก
Score 4 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
TBD
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
TBD
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
TBD
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
TBD
Current evidence: passages 1 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-05 ่บซ้ๆฌๅฉ่กๅๆนๆก / ๆฟ็ญ็ฝ็ฎๆธ่ฟฝ่นค
Score 5 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
TBD
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
TBD
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
TBD
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
TBD
Current evidence: passages 3 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-10 ็นๆฎๆ่ฒๅญธ็ไบบๆธ / ๅฎ็ฝฎๅๆ 12 ๅนดๆๅบ
Score 9 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
- Ministry of Education student-council operation data
- Child & youth representative selection records
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
- Child & youth representatives (5โ10 subjects)
- School student-council members
- Civil society child-participation organizations
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
- Ministry of Education โ student-council operational status
- Executive Yuan โ youth-representative policy impact
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
- CRC Article 12 (Right to be heard)
- CRC GR-12
Current evidence: passages 5 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-11 Disabled Family Caregivers
Score 11 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
TBD
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
TBD
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
TBD
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
TBD
Current evidence: passages 4 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRPD PI-09 Disability Employment Gap
Score 14 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
TBD
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
TBD
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
TBD
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
TBD
Current evidence: passages 6 ยท
events 0 ยท
cluster None ยท severity None
CRC PI-06 Children's Online Safety & Emerging Substances
Score 25 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
- NCC (้ๅณๆ) emerging-media statistics
- MOHW digital sexual-violence reporting
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
- Adolescent victims (with parental consent)
- School counselors
- Social workers
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
- NCC โ platform takedown enforcement
- NPA (่ญฆๆฟ็ฝฒ) โ child online-grooming investigations
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
- CRC GR-25 (Digital environment)
- CRC Articles 17, 34, 37
Current evidence: passages 17 ยท
events 3 ยท
cluster L ยท severity ้ซ
CEDAW PI-25 Women's Sports Fairness โ Fair Competition vs Gender Identity
Score 27 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
- Sports Administration โ gender ร sports participation statistics
- IOC transgender-athlete eligibility policy
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
- Female athletes (passively affected)
- Sports scholars
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
- Sports Administration โ transgender-athlete competition guidelines
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
- CEDAW Article 10 (Education incl. sports)
- CRPD Article 30 (Sports & culture)
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 6 ยท
cluster F ยท severity ้ซ
CEDAW PI-03 Glass Ceiling โ Women on Listed Boards / Women CEOs / Women Cabinet Members
Score 28 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
- TWSE listed-company annual reports โ women director ratios
- Ministry of Labor (ๅๅ้จ) Form 117 โ average wages by sex
- DGBAS (ไธป่จ็ธฝ่) โ senior management gender statistics
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
- Female CEOs / women directors of listed companies (5โ10 subjects)
- Heads of HR on the promotion ceiling
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
- DGBAS โ labor statistics broken down by job grade ร sex
- Ministry of Economic Affairs โ listed-company ESG gender-governance disclosure
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
- CEDAW GR-25 (Temporary Special Measures)
- CEDAW Article 11 (Employment)
Current evidence: passages 2 ยท
events 2 ยท
cluster A ยท severity ไธญ
CRC PI-10 Children's Right to Express Views & School Democracy
Score 28 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
- Ministry of Education student-council operation data
- Child & youth representative selection records
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
- Child & youth representatives (5โ10 subjects)
- School student-council members
- Civil society child-participation organizations
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
- Ministry of Education โ student-council operational status
- Executive Yuan โ youth-representative policy impact
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
- CRC Article 12 (Right to be heard)
- CRC GR-12
Current evidence: passages 17 ยท
events 4 ยท
cluster C ยท severity ไธญ
CEDAW PI-24 Women's Prison Custody Controversy โ Inmate Safety vs Gender Identity
Score 29 / Grade D๐ Data sources to collect
- Ministry of Justice โ Agency of Corrections statistical yearbook
- Control Yuan (็ฃๅฏ้ข) judicial human-rights reports
๐ฅ Interviews to conduct
- Female prisoners (post-parole)
- Prison social workers
- Women's crime-prevention scholars
๐จ Freedom-of-information requests
- Agency of Corrections โ transgender-inmate housing policy
- Prison gender ratio and vocational-training disparities
๐ Relevant international CO / GR
- CRPD Article 14 (Liberty)
- CEDAW Article 2 (Anti-discrimination)
Current evidence: passages 0 ยท
events 7 ยท
cluster F ยท severity ้ซ